Members of a remote tribe from the Amazon were murdered, according to the Brazilian
agency on indigenous affairs.
In an audio recording obtained by the agency, gold miners bragged about the massacre at
a bar near Colombian borders, saying it was a kill or be killed situation.
Joining me now to talk about this is RT correspondent Simone Del Rosario.
Let me ask you this.
First of all, what's the full story in this case, and how has it developed so far, Simone?
Where do you see this?
Well, Mike, Brazilian authorities are investigating reports, like you said, of a massacre up to
10 people that are from an isolated tribe in the Amazon, and this massacre was allegedly
carried out by illegal gold miners in the area.
This happened in the Javari Valley, which is the second largest indigenous reserve in
Brazil, and it allegedly took place in August.
Now, authorities only learned about it after these miners were caught bragging about it
a bar.
They spoke about cutting up these people's bodies, throwing them in the river.
The men also had a handmade paddle and a small bag that these tribesmen used for carrying
food, and these gold miners claimed they took it from their victims.
According to a government coordinator, there's a lot of evidence here, but this case still
needs to be proven.
A prosecutor did confirm the investigation is going on, but we're talking about a territory
that is vast.
The access to it is extremely limited.
Now, because these tribes are uncontacted, you can't just swoop in and investigate, bring
all of your law enforcement and authorities into this situation.
It's a very precarious situation.
It's going to require heavy involvement from Brazil's agency on indigenous affairs, FUNAI,
and as they work together with law enforcement to figure out if they can come up with these
bodies to prove this alleged massacre.
Simone, is this a first of its kind, or is this becoming a pattern that we're seeing
down there?
Well, according to the prosecutor in the region, this is the second case that he's seen this
year, and before that, he had never seen a case in this region before.
The first case that he saw happened in February of killing of uncontact indigenous people,
but just because he hasn't investigated cases before doesn't mean it hasn't happened elsewhere
in the country and in South America.
Earlier this summer, the UN warned that indigenous people in Brazil are specifically at risk.
They noted the country has seen the highest offenders of any country in the world over
the past 15 years.
They were averaging one murder a week, and then you have your recent figures.
They're even more startling.
According to Land Pastoral Commission, because of land disputes, more than 50 people have
been killed this year from January through July.
That's compared with 61 all of 2016.
That's indigenous groups, rural workers, and land activists that are being targeted here,
and usually it is from these illegal gold miners or loggers, though in some cases police
and the government are to blame for the violence.
Simone, you've reported, you've seen these cases firsthand, reported on them, basically,
these types of cases in a lot of places around the globe.
I'm wondering about this.
Brazil's President Michel Temer, he's getting a lot of heat for this incident.
Why are they blaming his government?
What are the grounds for pointing the finger at his direction, especially in this case?
Again, I say you've probably seen similar situations in other cases that you've followed
around the globe, but this is an interesting twist, let's blame the government rather than
the people who carried out the murder.
What's your take on this?
Well, people are starting to see a trend here, and they're making these connections.
A lot of people are making the connection to Temer's administration.
Now, the reason that could be is because FUNAI's funding, the group that oversees this, it's
been slashed, the agency on indigenous affairs.
Now, FUNAI was forced to close five of 19 bases that they use to monitor and protect
these isolated tribes, and then in the bases where they didn't have to close them, they
had to reduce the staffing.
Now, three of the closed bases of the five were in the Javari Valley, which is exactly
where this alleged massacre took place, and it's also home to 20% of the country's uncontacted
tribes.
To give you a picture of the slashed funding, in 2014, this group had a $2.4 million budget.
Now their budget is less than $650,000, and the director's saying, 'What do I do with
$650,000 to take care of all of these isolated tribes?'
On top of that, aside from just slashing funding, Temer is taking cover because of a corruption
scandal, something that we've been covering a lot of in Brazil, and he's doing so with
the help of the agriculture, ranching, and mining lobbies, and he's using them to be
able to push through economic reforms in Brazil, but to kind of pay them back, he's been making
policy changes that are really impacting deforestation and land rights happening in Brazil.
He also tried opening up a large reserve in the Amazon to mining.
Now, the judge blocked that, but mining and logging here are really the biggest threats
to indigenous communities right now, and as the president is trying to allow them into
this land, the constitution protects this land for these tribes that have been here
for longer than we can even imagine.
You know, Professors Robert Walker, I think, and Kim Hill coauthored articles that promoted
the need for controlled contact with these kinds of tribes, these remote tribes, they
believe to prevent incidents like what happened here.
What are they advocating, and what is your take on what they're advocating, Simone?
Well, Mike, according to Walker and Hill, this no-contact approach is not sustainable,
and actually they speculated that massacres like this alleged case would happen without
a controlled, peaceful contact.
In one paper the professors coauthored in 2015, they wrote that by refusing authorized,
well-planned contacts, governments are simply guaranteeing that accidental and disastrous
contacts will take place instead, and then this month, Professor Hill telling America's
lawyer that unfortunately, that speculation came true.
What they're advocating is that the governments initiate contact only after conceiving a very
well-organized plan.
I mean, previously, there's been poorly-planned contacts that have had devastating effects,
especially for these tribes, including death.
They need healthcare professionals and round-the-clock monitoring for more than a year after these
people were to give contact, so that's medical supplies and also food.
We're talking about really vulnerable populations.
They have no immunity to present-day diseases and infections.
They have not been affected by this yet.
In the '70s and '80s, there were a lot more contacts that was made with these tribes,
and that's when the population really suffered and the numbers of those populations were
slashed, so according to the professors, it has to be an incredibly orchestrated effort,
but they believe that isolated populations are not viable in the long-term, particularly
as their lands continue to be encroached on, as we're seeing happen now.
You know, Simone, you've got great experience down in this part of the world.
What do you think?
How does this end?
I mean, these tribal members were massacred, the worst kind of massacre, and so we're saying
this investigation is going to cure this?
How many times have you seen in third-world kinds of countries where there's been any
justice?
What is your personal take on whether there's going to be justice here, Simone?
Well, I can tell you this prosecutor that now has two cases, the ability for them to
be able to solve it is going to be very hard.
That first case they've been working on since February, and now we have a new case that
goes back to August, and it's taking miles and miles by boat even to get into these areas,
so it's a very challenging position, and the opinions on what is best for these tribes
really vary.
The UN and Brazil are on a no-contact approach, unlike what these professors are advocating
for, and it really depends on how you want to approach the situation, but there's arguments
for and against both.
The ability to get justice is going to be a little bit hard.
The fact that these miners were bragging about it might make it a little bit easier to track
them down eventually, but as long as you keep seeing the illegal activity happening in the
Amazon, and as long as outsiders can keep coming in and using this land for their benefit
and not paying respect to the people that live there and have their own way of life,
you're going to continue to see this happen.
It's probably going to be increasing, Mike.
Simone Del Rosario, thank you for joining me.
Thank you for being out there covering stories like this.
For more infomation >> Thursday PM: Latest information on Nate - Duration: 2:40. 
For more infomation >> Police arrest man after 2 carjacking incidents in York County - Duration: 0:57. 
For more infomation >> Witness in Sanborn case claims she was harassed - Duration: 0:50. 
For more infomation >> An emotional goodbye to deploying troops - Duration: 1:35. 
For more infomation >> Designated Survivor 2x03 Promo "Outbreak" (SUB ITA) - Duration: 0:31. 
For more infomation >> Hidden ballot boxes, encrypted texts How Catalans staged their referendum - Duration: 6:17. 
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét