THERE IS A STORY CIRCULATING AROUND THE INTERNET
INVOLVING A CASE THAT NEIL GORE
SUCH HEARD, AND ACTUALLY WAS ONLY THE DISSENTING JUDGE IN THE
CASE INVOLVING A TRUCK DRIVER WHO WAS FIRED BECAUSE HE
ABANDONED THE LOAD HE WAS DRIVING IN ILLINOIS.
IT SHOWS
THE TYPE OF PROCESS NEIL GORE
SUCH HAS WHEN HE IS RULING ON CASES.
AND HOW HE WANTS TO APPLY
THE LITERAL WORDING OF THE LAWS
THAT PERTAIN TO VARIOUS CASES.
THIS CASE HAS TO DO WITH A TRUCK
DRIVER AND APPARENTLY HE WAS DRIVING A TRUCK IN RURAL
ILLINOIS IN COLD TEMPERATURES AND HE WAS RUNNING OUT OF GAS.
HE WAS COMMUNICATING WITH HIS
EMPLOYERS ABOUT THE FACT THAT HE WAS GOING TO RUN OUT AND THEY
GAVE HIM THIS MUDDLED MESSAGE
ABOUT WHERE HE CAN REFUEL.
LONG STORY SHORT, HIS TRUCK STOPS
RUNNING.
HE FINDS HIMSELF
STRANDED IN RURAL ILLINOIS WITH THE TEMPERATURE AT -27∞F. AT
THAT POINT TRANSAM TOLD HIM YOU HAVE TO STICK AROUND IN AN HOUR
SOMEONE WILL BE THERE TO HELP
YOU.
ALTHOUGH NO ONE ENDED UP SHOWING UP
IN THE HOUR.
>> I JUST WANT TO EXPLAIN ONE PART THAT IS IMPORTANT AND NOT
SO CLEAR.
THERE IS A TRUCK, AND THEN A CABIN AND YOU CAN
SEPARATE THE TWO.
THE BRAKES ON THE TRUCK ARE FROZEN.
IF HE
TRIES TO GO OUT ON THE ROAD IT WILL BE SUPER DANGEROUS TO DRIVE
WITH THE BRAKES BASICALLY BROKEN.
AND HE HAS TO GO REALLY
SLOW BECAUSE THE BRAKES ARE ON
THE WHOLE TIME.
THEY ARE TELLING HIM EITHER DRIVE THE TRUCK OR
JUST WAIT THERE FOR SOMEONE TO COME OUT AND REPAIR.
IF THE
CABIN HEAT IS WORKING MAYBE HE
COULD PULL THAT OFF, BUT THAT LEADS TO THE NEXT PART OF THE
STORY.
>> EXACTLY.
HE ESSENTIALLY BUNDLED UP AND WAITED FOR THE
REPAIR MAN.
WHEN HE WOKE UP HE REALIZED HIS BODY WAS BLUE, HE
COULD FEEL HIS FEET AND HE WAS STARTING TO PANIC.
HE REALIZED
HE COULDN'T WAIT ANY LONGER.
THE MEAT WAS ABANDONED FOR A SHORT
PERIOD OF TIME SO HE COULD GO, REFUEL, AND COME BACK.
WHEN HE
CAME BACK THE REPAIR MAN WAS THERE, EVERYTHING WAS FINE.
HE
USED HUMAN JUDGMENT WHICH I THINK MOST PEOPLE WOULD USE IN
THIS SITUATION TO SAVE THEIR
LIVES.
THE COMPANY WAS WORKING FOR DECIDED TO FIRE HIM AND THIS
CASE WENT TO COURT.
>>BEFORE WE GET TO WHAT WAS DECIDED, THE HEAT IN THE CABIN
WAS NOT WORKING.
WHEN HE CHECKED THE TEMPERATURE GAUGE WITHIN THE
CABIN THREE HOURS LATER, HE WAITED LONGER THAN THE HOUR,
WITHIN THE CAR IT WAS -14∞.
HE COULDN'T FEEL HIS FEET AND WHEN
HE CALLED ONE OF HIS FRIENDS HE
WAS MUMBLING HIS SPEECH WHICH MEANT HE MIGHT'VE HAD
HYPOTHERMIA.
HE'S GOT TO GET OUT OF THERE, HE MIGHT DIE.
BUT
GORSUCH THANKS NO, WHEN A COMPANY GIVES YOU AN ORDER YOU
FOLLOW
IT.
>>HE IS VERY PRO-BUSINESS.
THIS CASE KEEPS COMING UP WITH WHY HE
SHOULDN'T BE CONFIRMED AS THE NEXT SUPREME COURT JUSTICE TO
REPLACE ANTONIN SCALIA.
THAT SHOWS YOU THE SPECIFICITY THAT
GORSUCH SPECIFIES ON WHEN MAKING THESE RULINGS.
FORGET HUMAN
JUDGMENT, FORGET THE FACT THAT THE LAW ACCORDING TO ALL THESE
OTHER JUDGES COULD APPLY IN THIS INDIVIDUALS AT DEFENSE.
BUT
GORSUCH RULES PRO-BUSINESS.
>>I THINK PEOPLE ARE BEING WAY TOO KIND FOR GORSUCH.
THIS CASE
WENT TO SEVEN DIFFERENT COURTS AND SEVEN DIFFERENT JUDGES.
EVERY OTHER JUDGE SAID HE IS CLEARLY RIGHT AND THE LAW DOES
APPLY TO HIM.
THEY CAN SAY HE COULD ARGUE THAT HE DIDN'T
OPERATE THE TRUCK PART.
YOU COULD ARGUE THAT THE LAW WAS
WRITTEN SLIGHTLY WRONG BUT IT IS OKAY BECAUSE THE DEPARTMENT OF
LABOR HAS THE ABILITY TO INTERPRET THAT LAW SO IT IS NOT
INTERPRETED IN AN ABSURD FASHION.
IT IS A VERY NORMAL
LEGAL DOCTRINE, IT'S CALLED THE CHEVRON DOCTRINE.
GORSUCH SAYS NO.
THE DEPARTMENT
OF LABOR CAN ACTUALLY INTERPRET
IT AND EVERY OTHER JUDGE IS SAYING THEY SHOULD.
HE IS LIKE
NO, I WILL NOT LET THEM DO THAT.
THE REASON WHY I SAY THEY ARE
BEING TOO KIND, IS A POINT ALL
THAT OUT.
BUT I WANT SOMEONE OUT THERE TO FIND ONE CASE WHERE
GORSUCH THAT I WILL ENFORCE
THE LAW LETTER BY LETTER IF IT WENT IN FAVOR OF A HUMAN BEING
AND NOT A CORPORATION.
I WANT TO SEE HIM RULE AGAINST A
CORPORATION BECAUSE HE ALMOST NEVER DOES.
I WOULD ARGUE HE
NEVER DOES.
HE HAS HAD EVERY OPPORTUNITY TO SAY YOU GUYS ARE
WRONG, HERE'S A CASE WHERE I RULED AGAINST CORPORATIONS
BECAUSE OF THE LETTER OF THE LAW.
HE HAS AN OVERWHELMING
RECORD OF SOMEHOW ALWAYS FINDING A LEGAL REASON TO RULE IN FAVOR
OF CORPORATIONS AND AGAINST
ACTUAL HUMAN BEINGS.
THESE ARE THE SAME CONSERVATIVE JUDGES
THAT HAVE THE AUDACITY TO SAY
THESE CORPORATIONS ARE PEOPLE.
AND GORSUCH WOULD LET THEM GET AWAY WITH IT.
>> WHEN ALPHONSE MADDEN GOT FIRED IT WAS LIKE A DEATH
SENTENCE FOR HIS CAREER.
HE HAD ONLY BEEN A TRUCK DRIVER FOR
THREE YEARS BECAUSE HE WAS A
GRAPHIC DESIGNER AND AFTER THE RECESSION WORK DRIED UP.
HE
STARTED DRIVING TRUCKS AND THAT WAS HIS ONLY MEANS OF MAKING
MONEY.
AFTER HE GOT FIRED AND IT SHOWED THAT HE HAD ABANDONED THE
PRODUCT HE WAS SUPPOSED TO DRIVE, PEOPLE WOULD NOT HIRE
HIM.
I CAN'T STAND THINGS LIKE ZERO-TOLERANCE POLICIES.
WHERE
PEOPLE IN POWER REFUSED TO USE HUMAN JUDGMENT THAT MAKES SENSE.
IF YOU DON'T WANT TO APPLY HUMAN JUDGMENT THEN YOU SHOULDN'T BE
ADJUDGED.
>>THERE IS THREE LAYERS OF CULPABILITY.
FIRST, LET'S THINK
ABOUT HOW MONSTROUS THIS COMPANY TRANSAM IS.
THEY TOLD THE GUY I
DON'T CARE IF IT IS -27∞, I DON'T CARE IF YOU ARE GOING TO
DIE, DON'T LEAVE THE PRODUCT BECAUSE IT MIGHT COST ME AN
EXTRA COUPLE BUCKS.
I AM A SMALL BUSINESS OWNER.
IF ONE OF YOU
GUYS CALLED ME AND SAID I AM
ABOUT TO DIE AND I SAID I DON'T CARE, WHAT KIND OF A MONSTER
WOULD I BE?
ALL THOSE GUYS IN THE MEDIA NEVER TALK ABOUT BIG
BUSINESS BECAUSE THEY ARE OWNED
BY IT.
WE HAVE SEEN BIG BUSINESS CRUSH US.
WHAT DOES THE CHAMBER
OF COMMERCE SAY?
THEY SAID
GORSUCH'S RULING WAS "FANTASTIC."
BECAUSE THE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
REPRESENTS MULTINATIONAL CORPORATIONS AND THEY DON'T CARE
ABOUT YOUR LIFE.
THEN GUYS LIKE GORSUCH CLAIM THEY ARE PEOPLE AND THEIR RIGHTS
SHOULD SUPERSEDE OUR RIGHTS WHO ARE ACTUAL AMERICAN CITIZENS.
>>THERE IS ONE THING THAT STOOD OUT TO ME IN THIS RULING, IT WAS
HOW GORSUCH WHO THINKS OF CORPORATIONS AS PEOPLE REFERRED
TO THE TRUCK DRIVER IN THIS CASE.
>> THE OTHER JUDGE THAT HUMANIZED AMUSED HIS NAME.
BUT
THE GORSUCH HE IS JUST A CLOG
IN THE MACHINE.
THIS IS THE THIRD LEVEL OF CULPABILITY AND
IT GOES TO GORSUCH A. YOU THINK HE DIDN'T KNOW WHAT HE WAS
DOING WHEN HE RULED AGAINST EVERY OTHER JUDGE?
THIS IS
IMPLANTING HIS FLAG SAYING I WILL BE MORE DRACONIAN,
PRO-BUSINESS THAN ANY OTHER
JUDGE OUT THERE.
SO TRUMP OR ANY OTHER REPUBLICAN, PICK ME, I
WILL SERVE THE CORPORATE
INTERESTS BETTER THAN ANYONE.
WHEN AL FRANKEN ASKED ABOUT HIM
ñ YOU HAVE TO GIVE HIM CREDIT ñ HE SAID LOOK I JUST WANT TO KNOW
WHAT WOULD YOU HAVE DONE IF YOU WERE ALPHONSO?
HE REFUSED TO
ANSWER THREE DIFFERENT TIMES.
EVEN PUTTING ASIDE YOUR LEGAL
POSITION IN THIS CASE I AM CURIOUS WHAT WOULD YOU HAVE DONE
IF YOU WERE HIM?
AND HE SAID I CAN'T SAY.
AL FRANKEN WAS LIKE
WHAT YOU MEAN?
WOULD YOU HAVE RISKED FREEZING TO DEATH
OR WOULD YOU HAVE GOTTEN FIRED?
THERE IS GORSUCH BASICALLY
TELLING REPUBLICANS DON'T WORRY,
I WILL NEVER SIDE ON THE SMALL GUY, I WILL ALWAYS BE ON THE
SIDE OF THE CORPORATIONS.
BY THE WAY THE FOUNDING FATHERS WERE
NOT ORIGINALISTS.
HIS REALITY IS HE DOESN'T CARE ABOUT THAT GUY,
HE CARES ABOUT HIS OWN PERSONAL
ADVANCEMENT.
HE CAN'T PUT HIMSELF IN HIS SHOES BECAUSE HE
IS A CONSERVATIVE.
>> IT IS THE INABILITY TO
EMPATHIZE AND PUT YOURSELF IN
THAT INDIVIDUAL SHOES.
THAT IS A HUGE PROBLEM WITH POLITICS IN
GENERAL RIGHT NOW.
I ACTUALLY WANT TO CALL MYSELF OUT.
I MADE
A HORRIBLE MISTAKE WHEN WE ORIGINALLY STARTED COVERING GORE
SUCH.
I SAID HE WASN'T SO BAD.
I SHOULD OF BEEN BETTER.
ERROR
NUMBER THE FIRST TIME I TALKED ABOUT HIM I SAID HE DIDN'T SOUND
THAT BAD, HE IS ACTUALLY EDUCATED AND I READ ALL THE
GLOWING REVIEWS ABOUT HIM IN THE MAINSTREAM MEDIA.
THAT WAS MY
MISTAKE.
WHEN IT COMES TO CASES
LIKE THIS HE IS A DEPLORABLE HUMAN BEING.
>> ALMOST THE ENTIRETY OF THE MAINSTREAM MEDIA IS ON GORSUCH'S
SIDE.
THE REASON THEY GIVE YOU IS THAT HE CAN SPEAK IN COMPLETE
SENTENCES.
THE REAL REASON IS THEY ARE ALSO CONTROLLED BY
GIANT MULTINATIONAL CORPORATIONS.
THEY ARE HIRED TO
LIKE GUYS LIKE GORSUCH.
FOR EXAMPLE, THE MORNING JOE CREW
WHO IS NOW ATTACKING TRUMP EVERY
DAY ñ THEY FIND A GUY LIKE THIS AND THE ESTABLISHMENT LOVES GORE
SUCH.
HE PUTS A GENTLE ELOQUENT FACE TO A REALLY DARK UGLY WORLD
THAT IS RULED BY THESE ROBOTS
THAT WE HAVE CREATED.
WE ARE IN THAT SCIENCE FICTION MOVIE.
THEY
ARE LEGAL ROBOTS CALLED PUBLIC
CORPORATIONS.
NOW THEY RULE US AND THEY GET THEIR HENCHMEN TO
COME IN AND SET THE RULES AND THE LAW SO WE CAN NEVER WIN.
YOU
EITHER DIE OR YOU GET FIRED.
BUT THE CORPORATION ALWAYS WINS
BECAUSE GORSUCH HELPS THEM FIND A WAY TO WIN IN EITHER
CASE.
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét